With multiple sclerosis, it’s less ‘do or do not’ and much more ‘try’

An edict from Yoda once served me well, but I've learned the attempt matters

Benjamin Hofmeister avatar

by Benjamin Hofmeister |

Share this article:

Share article via email
banner image for Ben Hofmeister's column

Even though I was too young to see the first three “Star Wars” films in theaters, I’ve watched them many, many times over the years. I don’t know if it’s the same everywhere, but here in the U.S., their enormous impact on pop culture is undeniable. Nearly everyone you meet can quote at least one line from the franchise, even if they’re not sure where it came from. The more devoted fans can describe the flora and fauna of various planets, name obscure characters, recite historical details, and frankly, get a little snooty with those of us who can’t.

Because of that, I’d better pause and point out that when I said the “first” three films, I meant the first three in order of release rather than narrative chronology. I don’t want to start any fights, especially not when I’m so disabled by my multiple sclerosis (MS). In my current condition, a dedicated squirrel could probably take me, so angering any “Star Wars” fanatics is something I’d like to avoid.

In case you were wondering why I went with a “Star Wars” theme for today’s column, it’s because Sunday is the unofficial “Star Wars” holiday. I can’t resist a well-made pun, and “May the fourth (“may the force”) be with you” is a pretty good one.

One line I can quote is from a scene in the second movie, where Luke Skywalker is training to become a Jedi under the tutelage of Yoda. When presented with a seemingly daunting task, Luke tells Yoda that he’ll give it a try. Yoda responds with, “No! Do, or do not. There is no try.”

It’s a good line and a philosophy that I’ve lived by the majority of my life. In a lot of situations, it’s completely applicable, but in my daily struggles with the symptoms of MS, it’s not.

I firmly believe that continuing to think that way for the first few years after my diagnosis caused me a lot of unnecessary grief. It took a little while for me to realize that I’m not trying to become a Jedi and don’t have to “do, or do not.” I’m trying to live with a progressive disease, and in that life, there is definitely a try.

How I try

Although I could in the past, I don’t walk now. When MS first started to affect my ability to do so, my mindset was to just do it harder. I didn’t want to use mobility aids or limit the time and distance that I could stay on my feet. In my mind, there was walking and not walking, with no room in between for trying or using the available assistive devices to compensate. Instead of doing, I didn’t do — and limited myself from the participation in life that trying would have allowed.

I cannot take a step or even stand up from my wheelchair without support. In the not-too-distant past, I would’ve decided that doing it with support was not really doing it, and I wouldn’t have tried. Trying and failing is not the same thing as giving up. Like so much in my journey with MS, I wish I’d realized that sooner.

I don’t write this column with a keyboard anymore. Voice to text may take me twice as long — mostly because I have to edit the software’s interpretation of my Southern accent — but to me it definitely counts as a try. I won’t deny that when my hand strength and finger dexterity started to go, I considered not writing anymore. I don’t know why I thought that the ability to type was an all-or-nothing thing, but I’m glad I tried assistive technology.

The “Star Wars” quote I referenced earlier isn’t the only one from the film that fits my daily life with MS. Sometimes when fatigue hits, or when I know, as soon as I get out of bed, that the day isn’t going to be a good one, I mutter, “I’ve got a bad feeling about this.” I also often tell my spastic and uncooperative legs that they “have failed me for the last time.” I’ve got others, but I’ll spare you for now.

What quotes from that franchise, or any other movie, do you use? Let me know in the comments below.


Note: Multiple Sclerosis News Today is strictly a news and information website about the disease. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. This content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website. The opinions expressed in this column are not those of Multiple Sclerosis News Today or its parent company, Bionews, and are intended to spark discussion about issues pertaining to multiple sclerosis.

Michael Honeycutt avatar

Michael Honeycutt

In my former life, 1977-80, I was assigned to an Amphibious Command and worked alongside a bunch of Navy SEALs, though not one myself. During one particularly difficult mission a Senior Chief reminded me of several things.
1. You are ALWAYS stronger than you think or feel like you are. It’s in there, you just have to practice digging it up.
2. You will live right up until the second you die, then you’re off on a different mission. Mission FIRST! Life is for the living so live, dammit!
3. Life is work and life is pain. Survival requires both. Pain is very uncomfortable and it can make you miserable but pain is rarely fatal. The mission now is staying alive. Improvise, adapt and overcome.

It’s helped me for over 45 years

Reply
Benjamin Hofmeister avatar

Benjamin Hofmeister

Thanks Michael! That's the kind of tough love I'm used to LOL. Not long after diagnosis, I was working a desk job and the commander of the operations Department came to talk to me one morning.

Hey Ben, you know who else has multiple sclerosis? Carlos Hathcock and he's doing fine.

I stared at him for a few minutes: No he's actually not. He passed away a few years ago. That's a terrible example.

Desperate to salvage this: but what did he die of?

Complications of his MS! Stop trying to cheer me up! You're really bad at it.

Reply
Steve Holt avatar

Steve Holt

Ben,
I have enjoyed reading your columns over the years, but this one is definitely one to remember. I have had the "Do or do not. There is no try." sign hanging in my office for many years and this message helps bring it home. Thanks for putting yourself out there and helping us to feel connected.

Reply
Benjamin Hofmeister avatar

Benjamin Hofmeister

You are very welcome Steve! I do this so I can feel connected and hearing that it makes others feel the same way is wonderful.

Reply
Heather avatar

Heather

Please keep on writing! I enjoy reading all of your articles, often more than once. You have helped me in so many ways. Your articles on MS have us look at things with a whole new perspective.

Reply
Benjamin Hofmeister avatar

Benjamin Hofmeister

Thank you for that Heather! I'll definitely keep writing because my perspective seems to adapt to the changes in my life from MS. Because of this, it doesn't look like I'm going to run out of material anytime soon LOL.

Reply
Tim Daun-Lindberg avatar

Tim Daun-Lindberg

Ben,
I love reading your articles! I identify with you so much. I was in the USAF in the late 70's, stationed at Minot AFB, working weapons control systems on F106 jets. I find your articles helpful, as I was diagnosed with primary progressive MS approximately two years ago. Like you were, I am still trying NOT to use adaptive equipment. The crazy part is I have walking poles and a walker. Your analogies to Star Wars are spot on. One of your beneficial articles was on "Toxic Hope". I shared the article with family and close friends and found I had to explain the idea behind toxic hope more than once. I have been the guy who pushes through, is task-oriented, and completes projects. The hardest part these days is the loss of independence. Please keep writing your articles, as they are so helpful to me. Feel free to email me.

Reply
Benjamin Hofmeister avatar

Benjamin Hofmeister

Thanks for that Tim! I was diagnosed while I was still in the army and started using a cane out of necessity, but I used trekking poles and a cane that didn't look like a medical cane because I equated that with giving in. I still don't like using a wheelchair (I don't think I have to), but I do realize that it's one of many tools that keeps me involved in my own life, so while I don't like it, I appreciate it.

Losing Independence is what I miss about driving. Friends and family assure me that they'll take me anywhere I want to go, but I have to tell them that it's really not about going somewhere. It's about the ability to go somewhere...on a whim even. I don't like the feeling of dependence, but like the wheelchair, I appreciate the people I depend on.

Reply
Natalie Sirota avatar

Natalie Sirota

Great article, Ben! I loved the Star Wars connections and May the 4th be with you! I feel your frustrations, I am starting down a neurological diagnosis path myself and can feel challenges already. Thanks for the inspiration to try.

Reply
Benjamin Hofmeister avatar

Benjamin Hofmeister

Thanks for reading Natalie! I never thought that trying could equal doing. I guess on this path, trying is sometimes the best we can do.

Reply

Leave a comment

Fill in the required fields to post. Your email address will not be published.