‘Pregnancy Compensation Hypothesis’ May Explain Greater MS Risk for Women

‘Pregnancy Compensation Hypothesis’ May Explain Greater MS Risk for Women

A mismatch — between the ancestral immune function changes induced by the placenta and fewer modern-day pregnancies — may help explain the greater risk for multiple sclerosis (MS) and other autoimmune diseases in women in industrialized societies, according to a new study.

The shift toward a sedentary lifestyle may further explain these gender differences.

The research with those findings, “The Pregnancy Pickle: Evolved Immune Compensation Due to Pregnancy Underlies Sex Differences in Human Diseases,” was published in the journal Trends in Genetics.

While women are substantially more susceptible to develop autoimmune diseases such as MS and lupus, men are at a higher risk of cancers such as melanoma and colon cancer. Differences in treatment effectiveness also exist, with women responding more favorably to cancer immunotherapies.

Reproductive hormones or environmental exposures alone cannot explain this distinction between genders. Differences in genes on sex chromosomes are independent of reproductive hormones, and could be key contributing factors. Yet, these sex differences remain largely unexplained.

“We are proposing a new theory called the Pregnancy Compensation Hypothesis,” Melissa Wilson, PhD, the study’s senior author, said in a press release written by Sandra Leander.

Her team at Arizona State University hypothesized that women’s ancestral immune system was shaped to facilitate their survival in the presence of the placenta, which induces anti-inflammatory changes to tolerate fetal antigens, while still allowing protection from disease-causing parasites and pathogens.

Both reproductive hormones and heritable variations in sex chromosome content mediate these differences in immune function.

Scientists also propose that reduced pregnancy rates in industrialized societies aggravate the risk of autoimmune disease. This could help explain why autoimmune diseases are more common in industrialized than non-industrialized communities. Specifically, the team believes that the immune system has evolved to respond to a given amount of challenges, including the effects of the placenta. With a lesser load, the immune system attacks “self” targets, while also responding better to cancer.

“Now, in a modern, industrialized society, women are not pregnant all the time so they don’t have a placenta pushing back against the immune system. The changes in their reproductive ecology exacerbate the increased risk of autoimmune disease because immune surveillance is heightened. At the same time, we see a reduction in some diseases, like cancer,” Wilson said.

Angela Garcia, a co-author of the study, added: “There is a mismatch between the ancestral environment humans were adapted to, and the industrialized environment many people currently live in.” Garcia also pointed to the shift to a sedentary lifestyle, one in which the “overabundance of calories available,” that may lead to excessive levels of hormones such as estrogen and progesterone.

“Maintaining such high levels of hormones may increase the chance of triggering autoimmune diseases,” Garcia said.

Looking ahead, researchers proposed that sex differences in the immune system should be taken into account when developing treatments.

“Our goal is to actually make treatments better for everyone,” said Heini Natri, PhD, the study’s lead author. “Understanding the evolutionary origin of the sex bias in these diseases can help us better understand the mechanisms and particular pieces of the immune system we can target.”

“In the study of most cancers and other diseases, and so far in the development of cancer treatments, that has not really been taken into account,” Natri said.

Ken Buetow, PhD, also a study co-author, emphasized the importance of assessing immune differences between men and women, as well as their changes over time, to help find new ways to prevent cancer and autoimmune diseases.

“We think this is more than a hypothesis,” Buetow said. “We anticipate that the sex differences in immune function will, to some extent, contribute to sex differences in all human diseases,” the team wrote.

Evaluating unique gene regulation patterns in men and women, and assessing environmental variables such as the exposure to pathogens, levels of stress and reproductive hormones, are among other important aspects looking forward. “We have to understand these areas better,” Wilson concluded.


  1. Frank Havnoonian says:

    Did anyone ever consider that a drop in Vitamin D blood levels as mom is feeding in utero would cause a jump in auto immune disorders?????Vitamin D is a powerful aid in the immune system to “clean up” many disorders.

  2. Holliemetcalf says:

    Prolactinomadecreased after pregnancy.microadenomapituitary came in its place .Then ms came 10or more years to diagnose ms nowsecondaryprogressive.hormones at play?

  3. Tim Carter says:

    Wow. Last article I read in this newsletter stated that higher estrogen levels could benefit the maintaining of the blood brain barrier thereby helping fight ms, but this article is stating that estrogen may be harmful? Dr. Perlmetter makes a neat observation in his book Brain Maker that through higher rates of c section deliveries and less and less breast feeding that babies are not getting essential microbial bacteria to set immune systems in early development. Add early exposure to environmental toxins and possible damaging exposure to antibiotics and you could have a perfect storm for auto immune conditions. Now food companies are boasting no antibiotics ever for meats like chicken or beef. Wasn’t even considered 15 yrs ago. Seems they may be on to something. May not be the fact that women are pregnant less, but rather the methods that they are using to have and feed the babies. 3 or 4 generations of c sections and formula feeding could very well be damaging how the immune system is being formed.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This