Peeking Behind the Curtain at Medical Insurance Decisions
Several years ago, I tried to get my insurance company to approve a functional electronic stimulator (FES). It’s a durable medical device that significantly improved my left foot drop. My request was well-supported by documentation from my neurologist and the physical therapist who was evaluating me for the FES. With the device, a Bioness L300, I was more stable, walked faster, and my risk of falling was decreased. But my insurance company denied the $6,000 device and my two appeals were also turned down.
I wasn’t particularly surprised when I later learned that the doctor who denied my final appeal had no background in neurology, physiology, or treating MS, but I was a bit angry.
CNN report draws back the curtains
Fast-forward a number of years to 2018. The insurance commissioner in California recently launched an investigation into Aetna‘s insurance practices after learning that a former medical director for the insurer admitted under oath that he never looked at patients’ records when deciding whether to preapprove care.
CNN obtained a transcript of videotaped testimony by Dr. Jay Ken Iinuma in a lawsuit brought by a 23-year-old college student in California who has a rare immune disorder. The patient sued Aetna for alleged breach of contract and bad faith because Iinuma denied pre-authorization for an infusion the student needed a few years ago. His suit alleges that Aetna’s “reckless withholding of benefits almost killed him.”
Iinuma served as medical director for Aetna in Southern California from 2012 to 2015, and he’s the person who denied the treatment. According to the CNN report, “Iinuma — who signed the pre-authorization denial — said he never read [the patient’s] medical records and knew next to nothing about his disorder.”
CNN continues:
How widespread is the problem?
Knowledge is power
About the Author
Laurie Warner
United Healthcare recently denied me the prescription Ampyra for an unknown reason. I have been taking it for years. I was without it for four days before they reversed their decision after an appeal by my neurologist. I tried to be careful walking, but day three and day four I fell. Luckily, I didn’t hurt myself, but it could have been much worse. Does UHC think it would be cheaper for them to deny me the prescription Ampyra? Maybe. But it also could have cost them more in hospital bills for broken bones and/or a concussion, and then subsequent rehabilitation.
Ed Tobias
Hi Laurie,
Yes, it's very discouraging that the larger healthcare picture is almost never taken into account when these decisions are made. :-(
Ed
Jerry Corras
You don’t get an auto mechanic to fix your teeth. You just have to shake your head sometimes at insurance companies. ?
GARY SHAMBLEN
I faced the same FES issue. After 2 denials my Neurologist made things clear to the insurance that for me this device is a "Medical Necessity". The last meeting was what the ins. co. called a Peer to Peer Conference where they are to have a doctor of same field as my Neurologist. They would set the telephone conference time and then their Dr. would not be available when called. Finally when the conference was held the first question my Dr. asked was "are you a Neurologist"? Answer-No. My Dr. told them to get a real Dr. as he was not there to waste his time. At that point they said they would try to do something on the claim. My insurance does specifically say that certain such devices are not covered. but they did pay about 40%. Just another example of the level of incompetence and deception that we patients are dealing with. They will try anything to delay, discourage, and even deceive to improve their bottom line. New innovations are coming out continually, especially in medicine, but having access depends on having money. Besides, we have a multi-billion dollar wall to build. There needs to be a nationwide legislative movement toward patient care for a better quality of life. Our elected officials are there because of our vote. That needs made much clearer to them.
Ed Tobias
Good for you, Gary. Thanks for fighting the fight.
Ed